The alternatives compared
There are four common replacements for an oil boiler or electric heating. They differ in whether they replace the whole heating system, whether they heat domestic hot water and what they require from the plot.
Recommended
Air-to-water heat pump
In Finnish: ilma-vesilämpöpumppu, ilmavesilämpöpumppu, vesi-ilmalämpöpumppu, VILP or vilppi
- Replaces main heating
- Yes
- Heats domestic hot water
- Yes
- Investment
- Moderate
- Works in frost
- Down to −25…−28 °C
Suits: most detached houses with oil or electric heating. The outdoor unit is installed next to the house wall, and no drilling is needed.
Costly to install
Ground source heat pump
Borehole and ground source heat pump
- Replaces main heating
- Yes
- Heats domestic hot water
- Yes
- Investment
- Largest
- Requires
- Drilling and a permit
Keep in mind: drilling is the largest single cost, and a borehole needs a building permit. It is normally placed at least 7.5 metres from the plot boundary, and metro tunnels, groundwater areas and neighbours’ boreholes restrict drilling.
Supplementary heater
Air-source heat pump
Blows warm air into the rooms
- Replaces main heating
- No
- Heats domestic hot water
- No
- Investment
- Smallest
- Cools in summer
- Yes
Suits: supplementary heating and cooling. It does not replace an oil boiler, heat the radiator system or heat domestic hot water.
Within the network
District heating
The energy company’s heating network
- Replaces main heating
- Yes
- Heats domestic hot water
- Yes
- Investment
- Connection fee
- Availability
- Only within the network
Keep in mind: the network does not reach every residential area, and the price of heat is set by the energy company.
The heat source is only half of it
This comparison is about the heat source, i.e. what produces the heat. The heat distribution, i.e. how the heat is carried to the rooms, is chosen separately: water-based underfloor heating or new energy-efficient radiators. An air-to-water heat pump works best when the heat distribution is sized for a low water temperature.