Skip to content
FI – Suomeksi 050 322 5922

Heating alternatives

Alternatives to oil and electric heating

Oil and electric heating are expensive to run, and many detached houses are looking for a replacement. This comparison covers the most common alternatives and explains why we recommend an air-to-water heat pump for most houses in the Helsinki region.

The alternatives compared

There are four common replacements for an oil boiler or electric heating. They differ in whether they replace the whole heating system, whether they heat domestic hot water and what they require from the plot.

Recommended

Air-to-water heat pump

In Finnish: ilma-vesilämpöpumppu, ilmavesilämpöpumppu, vesi-ilmalämpöpumppu, VILP or vilppi

Replaces main heating
Yes
Heats domestic hot water
Yes
Investment
Moderate
Works in frost
Down to −25…−28 °C

Suits: most detached houses with oil or electric heating. The outdoor unit is installed next to the house wall, and no drilling is needed.

Costly to install

Ground source heat pump

Borehole and ground source heat pump

Replaces main heating
Yes
Heats domestic hot water
Yes
Investment
Largest
Requires
Drilling and a permit

Keep in mind: drilling is the largest single cost, and a borehole needs a building permit. It is normally placed at least 7.5 metres from the plot boundary, and metro tunnels, groundwater areas and neighbours’ boreholes restrict drilling.

Supplementary heater

Air-source heat pump

Blows warm air into the rooms

Replaces main heating
No
Heats domestic hot water
No
Investment
Smallest
Cools in summer
Yes

Suits: supplementary heating and cooling. It does not replace an oil boiler, heat the radiator system or heat domestic hot water.

Within the network

District heating

The energy company’s heating network

Replaces main heating
Yes
Heats domestic hot water
Yes
Investment
Connection fee
Availability
Only within the network

Keep in mind: the network does not reach every residential area, and the price of heat is set by the energy company.

The heat source is only half of it

This comparison is about the heat source, i.e. what produces the heat. The heat distribution, i.e. how the heat is carried to the rooms, is chosen separately: water-based underfloor heating or new energy-efficient radiators. An air-to-water heat pump works best when the heat distribution is sized for a low water temperature.

Ground source or air-to-water heat pump?

Ground source heat is efficient, but efficiency alone does not make it worthwhile. Drilling the borehole is the largest cost of the purchase, and many rules restrict where a borehole can go, especially in the densely built Helsinki region. Modern air-to-water heat pumps have narrowed the gap in running costs so much that, in most detached houses, the extra cost of drilling is no longer justified. That is why we focus on air-to-water heat pumps.

What restricts drilling a borehole?

  • Permit: a borehole needs a building permit, and the drilling water must be treated before it is discharged from the site.
  • Distance to the boundary: the borehole is normally placed at least 7.5 metres from the neighbour’s boundary and the street centreline. Closer only with the neighbour’s written consent.
  • Other wells and buildings: the Ministry of the Environment guide recommends 15 metres to another borehole, 40 metres to a drilled water well and 3 metres to a building. On a small plot, a suitable spot cannot always be found.
  • Metro and other underground spaces: tunnels, rock caverns and underground space reservations restrict drilling. The guide recommends 25 metres to tunnels, checked case by case.
  • Groundwater areas and contaminated soil: drilling in a groundwater area requires special protective measures, and Helsinki’s guidance does not allow boreholes in groundwater areas. A permit is hardly ever granted on contaminated land.
  • Wells affecting each other: boreholes close together take energy from each other, so the rock cools and the heating output can weaken over the years. That is why Helsinki requires that a borehole field must not cool the neighbour’s boundary by more than 2 °C over 50 years.

Sources: Ministry of the Environment energy well guide (Ympäristöopas 2013), City of Helsinki geothermal guidance and City of Espoo building control guidance (in Finnish). Always check the current rules with your municipality’s building control.

An air-to-water heat pump needs no drilling

  • No drilling and no drilling restrictions — installation is possible on almost any plot
  • A clearly smaller investment than ground source heat
  • Models designed for northern conditions operate at temperatures as low as −25 to −28 °C
  • Heats both the house and the domestic hot water
  • Savings of 60–80 % compared with oil or electric heating, depending on the property

How is your house heated now?

Oil heating

The house already has radiators, but they were sized for the hot water of an oil boiler. The boiler is replaced with an air-to-water heat pump and the heat distribution is renewed to be energy-efficient.

Replacing oil heating

Electric heating

With water-based electric heating, the heat pump replaces the electric boiler. A house with direct electric heating also gets a water-based heat distribution system.

Replacing electric heating

Still comparing?

The savings calculator gives a rough estimate straight away. An energy calculation shows the exact savings and does not commit you to anything.

Savings calculator

Heating alternatives — frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to oil heating?

In most detached houses in the Helsinki region, an air-to-water heat pump. It heats both the house and the domestic hot water and needs no drilling. When the old radiators and heating pipes are renewed at the same time, the heat pump runs at its best efficiency. The exact answer for your house comes from the energy calculation.

Is an air-source heat pump enough to replace oil heating?

No. An air-source heat pump cannot be the main heat source of a house: it assists with heating and provides cooling in summer. It does not heat the radiators or the domestic hot water, so it cannot replace an oil boiler. An air-source heat pump and an air-to-water heat pump are different units, even though the names are similar. An oil boiler is replaced by an air-to-water heat pump.

Why do you not install ground source heat pumps?

Drilling a borehole is expensive, and it needs a building permit. A borehole normally has to be at least 7.5 metres from the plot boundary, and metro tunnels, other underground spaces and groundwater areas restrict drilling. In densely built areas, boreholes close together also take energy from each other. In most detached houses, a modern air-to-water heat pump gives better overall value.

Does an air-to-water heat pump work in hard frost?

Yes. Models designed for northern conditions operate at temperatures as low as −25 to −28 °C, and the sizing makes sure the output is enough in the hardest frosts too.

Request an energy calculation

Tell us how your house is heated now and we will calculate what the switch would save. The calculation does not commit you to anything.

+358 50 322 5922

Energy calculation request form